She’s the He: Siobhan McCarthy’s Indie Trans Comedy (SXSW 20025)

‘She’s the He’ Tackles the ‘Fear Around Every Corner’ of Trump Era

In the indie comedy “She’s the He,” which premiered at SXSW, high school seniors Alex and Ethan decide during the last week to pretend they’re trans so they can sneak into the women’s locker room.

The timely premise seems lifted out of MAGA-era attacks on trans rights.

First-time writer-director Siobhan McCarthy dreamed up the idea in February 2024, after discovering online the high school comedy that spoke to them as teenager: Amanda Bynes 2006 comedy She’s the Man.

With their friend, Will Geare (who co-edited “She’s the He” with McCarthy), about the kinds of trans stories they both wished they’d been able to see when they were younger.

My Book:

McCarthy finished the first draft of “She’s the He” a few days later, and by July, they were shooting the film with a cast and crew that was entirely made up of trans, nonbinary and queer people — including the background actors. McCarthy leaned heavily on the tiny network of trans professionals within the industry.

“It was incredibly difficult to not only find trans people to be in a film — and this many trans people, which is unprecedented — but to then find the right people for the roles we were trying to cast, which is the goal of any film,” McCarthy says.

Trans actor Emmett Preciado (“Good Trouble”) landed the role of the school’s jacked, bullying quarterback, Jacob, through a recommendation from McCarthy’s friend, trans actor and activist Ian Alexander. After McCarthy cast queer actor Malia Pyles (“Pretty Little Liars: Original Sin”) as the hottest and most popular girl in school, Pyles’ boyfriend, trans actor Jordan Gonzalez, suggested casting Misha Osherovich (“Freaky”) for the film’s critical central role, Ethan — who, after pretending to be trans, realizes that she actually is trans. And McCarthy didn’t find comedian Nico Carney, who ended up playing Ethan’s horn-dog BFF Alex, until a week before filming started.
“I had no idea if he could act,” McCarthy says. “I’d just seen his stand up. When we got into that rehearsal room the first day and he did the first scene, I finally, finally breathed a sigh of relief, because I knew we had a movie.”

After “She’s the He” opened to a standing ovation, McCarthy spoke about their inspirations for the movie, the “painful” experience of making it during the 2024 presidential election, and why they hope the film — which does not yet have distribution — will make it into movie theaters.

Nico Carney, Tatiana Ringsby and Siobhan McCarthy at the “She’s The He” premiere, SXSW Film Fest, March 9, 2025  Diego Donamaria

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter