Oklahoma! (1955) Musical Film, Helmed by Wrong Director, Fred Zinnemann

The wrong director, Fred Zinnemann, got assigned to direct the big-screen version of the Broadway musical hit, Oklahoma!

The seminal 1943 Broadway production, often hailed as the musical that changed the course of the American theater from revues to book musicals, focusing on character and plot.

The songs of Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein are great, but Zinnemann, a humorless director who knew nothing about musicals, gave it a pedestrian treatment that resulted in one of the weakest adaptations of the 1950s.

Zinnemann got the assignment due to his increased status in the industry, a result of winning Best Director, Best Picture and other Oscars for From Here to Eternity, the most hailed movie of 1953.

The fault is not entirely his. Screenwriter Sonya Levien and William Ludwig could not find an interesting way to open up the musical cinematically, and the composers’ insistence that not one word be changed from their stage version didn’t help either.

Still, “Oklahoma! was very popular with audiences, due to their familiarity with the Broadway production and/or glorious music.

Oscar Context

The movie received four Oscar nominations, winning two:

Sound Recording to Fred Hynes (of the Todd-AO Department)

Scoring of a Musical Picture to Robert Russell Bennett, Jay Blackton, and Adolph Deutsch.

The other two nominations were for Color Cinematography to multiple nominee Robert Surtees, and Film Editing to Gene Ruggiero and George Boemler.

However, the Cinematography Oscar went to another Robert, Robert Burk, for Hitchcock’s “To Catch a Thief,” and the Editing to Charles Nelson and William A. Lyon for Joshua Logan’s “Picnic.”

Gordon MacRae as Curly McLain
James Mitchell as Curly in the dream sequence (dancer)
Shirley Jones as Laurey Williams
Bambi Linn as Laurey in the dream sequence (dancer)
Gene Nelson as Will Parker
Gloria Grahame as Ado Annie Carnes
Charlotte Greenwood as Aunt Eller
Rod Steiger as Jud Fry
Eddie Albert as Ali Hakim
James Whitmore as Andrew Carnes
Barbara Lawrence as Gertie Cummings
Jay C. Flippen as Skidmore
Roy Barcroft as Marshal

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter