How Green Was My Valley (1941): John Ford’s Sentimental Family Drama Wins Over Citizen Kane

John Ford’s 1941 How Green Was My Valley was a smash-hit at the box-office even before earning its multiple Oscar nominations (and later awards).
Grade: B+ (**** out of *****)
How Green Was My Valley
How Green Was My Valley (1941 poster - Style A).jpg

Theatrical release poster

Ford’s film was critically acclaimed, celebrating what the N.Y. Times critic Bosley Crowther described as “the majesty of plain people,” and “the beauty which shines in the souls of simple, honest folk.”

Indeed, “How Green Was My Valley” reaffirmed Ford’s populist ideology, propagated the year before in another Oscar-nominated family saga, “The Grapes of Wrath,” starring Henry Fonda. Nonetheless, “How Green” was not associated with the anger and leftist politics of John Steinbeck, the author’s book, upon which “Grapes of Wrath” was based.

how_green_was_my_valley_5_crispBased on Richard Llewellyn’s novel, adapted to the screen by Philip Dunne, “How Green” tells the story of a Welsh mining family, narrated by its youngest son, Huw Morgan (child actor Roddy McDowall). Ford’s idealized view of the past is seen through the memory of the boy, surrounded as he is by a large, loving family. As in other films, Ford draws parallels between the breakdown of the Morgan family and that of the surrounding community, and by implication America society at large.

“How Green Was My Valley” is one of Ford’s most lyrically beautiful, if also sentimental, pictures. The critic Andrew Sarris has described the movie as an elegiac poem, and for many it was. The film’s portrayal of the disintegration of a mining community is of epic and heroic dimensions.

Nominated for ten Oscars, the film won five, honoring Ford’s Direction, Arthur Miller’s Cinematography and Art direction. Sara Allgood was nominated for Supporting Actress, as the gentle but strong mother, Beth Morgan, and Donald Crisp won the Supporting Actor Oscar for playing Mr. Morgan, the stern patriarch who is later killed in the mine.

how_green_was_my_valley_3_crispNot to be underestimated is the fact that “How Green” film was selected by the Academy voters while the U.S. had already been involved in the War. The film’s warmly sympathetic depiction of family unity must have hit deep chords in the country’s collective consciousness, which may explain, at least in part, why its two major competitors, Orson Welles’s masterpiece, “Citizen Kane” and William Wyler’s “The Little Foxes,” each with nine nominations, were the losers. Both films, and particularly “Little Foxes,” represented dark and somber visions of the American family. Once again, the “right” contents and ideological approach made the difference, though it is noteworthy that “How Green” was as visually distinguished, as it was thematically acceptable.

After winning the 1941 Oscars, Fox’s Darryl Zanuck told his colleagues: “When I think of what I got away with, and won the Academy Award with the picture, it is really astonishing. Not only did we drop five or six characters, we eliminated the most controversial element in the book, which was the labor-and-capital battle in connection with the strike.”

Indeed, there was nothing really divisive or particularly agitating and provocative about this well made, enjoyable film, which focuses on the family as a scared institution.

Detailed Plot

how_green_was_my_valley_1_crispA monologue by the older Huw Morgan (voiced by Irving Pichel) begins the story: “I am packing my belongings in the shawl my mother used to wear when she went to the market. And I’m going from my valley. And this time, I shall never return.” The camera then tracks the valley and its villages blackened by the surrounding coal mines.

Huw (Roddy McDowall), the youngest child of Gwilym Morgan (Donald Crisp), walks home with his father to meet his mother, Beth (Sara Allgood). His older brothers, Ianto (John Loder), Ivor (Patric Knowled), Davy (Richard Fraser), Gwilym Jr and Owen work in the coal mines with their father, while his sister Angharad (Maureen O’Hara) helps their mother with domestic chores.

Huw’s childhood is idyllic, warm and loving family in a town not yet overrun withmining effects. Huw is smitten when he meets Bronwyn (Anna Lee) engaged to his oldest brother, Ivor). At the wedding party, Angharad meets the new preacher, Mr. Gruffydd (Walter Pidgeon).

When the mine owner lowers the wages, the miners protest with a strike. Gwilym’s attempt to mediate, but his effort estranges him from the other miners and his older sons, motivating Beth to interrupt a meeting, threatening to kill anyone who harms her husband. While returning home, Beth falls into the river, and Huw dives in to save her. Temporarily losing one of his legs, he later recovers with the help of Mr Gruffydd.

The strike is eventually settled, and Gwilym and his sons reconcile, but many miners lose their jobs. Angharad is courted by the mine owner’s son Iestyn Evans (Marten Lamont), though her heart is set on Mr Gruffydd, who loves her too. The gossipy townswomen can’t bear the idea of Angharad living impoverished life, and she submits to a loveless marriage to Evans.

Huw begins school at a nearby village, and bullied by the other boys, he is taught to fight by boxer Dai Bando (Rhys Williams) and Cyfartha (Barry Fitzgerald).

Bronwyn gives birth to their child the same day Ivor is killed in a mine accident. Later, the four Morgan sons are fired and less experienced, cheaper laborers replace them. With no job prospects, they seek their fortunes abroad. Huw is awarded a scholarship to university, but he declines it in order to work in the mines. He moves in with Bronwyn to help provide for her and her child.

The alarm whistle sounds signal another mine disaster, in which some men are injured, and Gwilym and others are trapped. Young Huw, Mr. Gruffydd, and Dai Bando descend with others in a rescue attempt. Gwilym and his son are reunited before he dies of his injuries. Huw cradles his father’s body, with his coal-blackened face revealing loss of innocence.

The film ends just as it began, with narration by the older Huw: “Men like my father cannot die. They are with me still, real in memory as they were in flesh, loving and beloved forever. How green was my valley then.”

In the film’s last images, we observe some touching vignettes of Huw and his family.


Walter Pidgeon as Mr. Gruffydd, pastor of the village chapel
Maureen O’Hara as Angharad Morgan
Donald Crisp as Gwilym Morgan
Roddy McDowall as Huw Morgan
Sara Allgood as Mrs. Beth Morgan
Anna Lee as Bronwyn, Ivor’s wife
Patric Knowles as Ivor Morgan
John Loder as Ianto Morgan
Barry Fitzgerald as Cyfartha, boxing manager
Rhys Williams as Dai Bando, boxer
Morton Lowry as Mr. Jonas, school teacher
Arthur Shields as Mr. Parry, deacon
Frederick Worlock as Dr. Richards
Richard Fraser as Davy Morgan
Evan S. Evans as Gwilym Morgan Jr.
James Monks as Owen Morgan
Ethel Griffies as Mrs. Nicholas, housekeeper
Lionel Pape as Mr. Evans senior
Marten Lamont as Iestyn Evans, his son
Ann E. Todd as Ceinwen, school girl
Clifford Severn as Mervyn Phillips, school bully
Irving Pichel as adult Huw Morgan )unseen narrator)


Directed by John Ford
Produced by Darryl F. Zanuck
Screenplay by Philip Dunne, based on How Green Was My Valley by Richard Llewellyn
Narrated by Irving Pichel
Music by Alfred Newman
Cinematography Arthur C. Miller
Edited by James B. Clark
Distributed by Twentieth Century-Fox Film Corporation

Release date: October 28, 1941

Running time: 118 minutes
Budget $800,000
Box office $2.4 million