Everyone Says I Love You, Woody Allen’s romantic comedy, is a tribute to Hollywood classics films of the 1930s, specifically Frank Capra’s “You Can’t take It With You,” which won the 1938 Best Picture Oscar.
| I Love You | |
|---|---|
Theatrical release poster
|
|
|
|
|
Grade: C+ (** out of *****)
This is one of Allen’s large ensemble pieces, with a stellar cast that includes himself, Julia Roberts, Goldie Hawn, Tim Roth, and the discovery of the year, Edward Norton (who the same year made a memorable impression in the horror-thriller, Primal Fear).
Sharply uneven, the film contains some witty line and funny gags, but the overall impact is that of a well-intentioned but finally a mediocre effort.
The setting is again the top crust of Manhattan’s Upper East Side. The tale is narrated by DJ (Natasha Lyonne), who guides the viewers through the fables and foibles of a large extended family, headed by Alan Alda and Goldie Hawn.
DJ’s half-sister (Drew Barrymore) is engaged to be married to a shy, mild-manner introvert (Edward Norton), but she is smitten with a more daring man, who is a former con (Tim Roth).
As DJ’s biological father, Woody Allen may be too old (he was 61 when the film was made) to court and have love scenes with Julia Roberts, who plays an unhappily married femme. Roberts, who’s half of Allen’s age, is miscast, and there’s no chemistry between her and Allen (no wonder she goes back to her husband at the end!).
Switching locale (and running out of ideas), the family goes to Paris for Christmas and attends a Groucho Marx-themed New Years party. When Bob comes down with a cold, Steffi attends with Joe and they acknowledge that, though they didn’t work out, they still have feelings for each other. Steffi encourages Joe to find someone who will make him happy.
The family dances to “Everyone Says I love You” as DJ falls for a dance partner in Harpo Marx costume.
The attempt to integrate songs, delivered by ordinary characters in mundane situations, is original but only semi-successful.
Even so, the film is warm-hearted and well shot by Italian cinematographer Carlo Di Palma.
Spending a short time (running time is only 97 minutes) with this glorious cast offers undeniable if forgettable pleasure, even if most of the characters have only two or three scenes.
The movie was a commercial flop, earning less than $10 million, which amounted to half of its production budget.
Cast
Joe (Woody Allen)
Von (Julia Roberts)
Steffi (Goldie awn)
Charles Ferry (Tim Roth)
Bob (Alan Alda)
Holden (Edward Norton)
DJ (Natasha Lyonne)
Scott (Lukas Haas)
Holden’s father (Donald Ogden Stiers)
Running time: 97 minutes.
