All Quiet on the Western Front (1930): Lewis Milestone’s Best Picture Oscar

If Wings, the first Oscar-winning war film, celebrates heroism, action, and male camaraderie, All Quiet on the Western Front, the third Best Picture (for 1930) delivers a more powerful, anti-war, message.

 

Our Grade: A- (****1/2 out of *****)

all_quiet_poster.jpg
Based on Eric Maria Remarque’s famous novel, adapted to the screen by a team of writers headed by playwright Maxwell Anderson, Dell Andrews, and George Abbott, the story describes the initial excitement and then disillusionment of a group of German soldiers in the First World War, none of whom survives.

Uncompromisingly made, the film makes a clearly bleak statement of war fighting in trenches, stressing the inanity of war for both sides, the Allies and the German.

All Quiet on the Western Front contains many powerful scenes–and speeches.  Expressing some German dogface philosophy at the frontlines, Louis Wolheim states: “I tell you how it should all be done.  Whenever there’s a big war coming, you should rope off a big field and sell tickets. And, on the big day, you should take all the kings and cabinets and their generals, put them in the center dressed in their underpants and let them fight it out with clubs. The best country wins. 

all_quiet_2.jpg

When Lew Ayres finds a Frenchman (Raymond Griffith) in a shell-hole and stabs him, only to agonize later over what he has done.  He says: “When you jumped in here, you were my enemy–and I was afraid of you. But you’re just a man like me, and I killed you. Forgive me! Oh, no, you’re dead! You’re better off than I am–you’re through–they can’t do anymore to you now. Oh, God! why did they do it to us? We only wanted to live, you and I. Why should they send us out to fight each other? If we threw away these rifles and these unifomrs, you could be my brother, just like Kate and Albert. You’ll have to forgive me, comrade.”

Later on, in the film’s memorable penultimate scene, Ayres sees a butterfly and spontaneously reaches out to touch it, when he is hit with a bullet. One by one, the soldiers are maimed or killed in action.

all_quiet_3.jpg

The anti-war message is loud and clear. Lew Ayres, addressing a classroom full of potential soldiers, says war: “When it comes to dying for your country, it’s better not to die at all.” 

“All Quiet on the Western Front” proved to be a huge success at the box-office; it was Universal’s biggest hit. Reissued in the U.S. in 1939, in a substantially truncated version (the initial running time was 145 minutes), the movie enjoyed a second successful run and it’s often shown on TV. In later reissues, the opening commentary, on the horror and futility of war, was excised from the original.

The film was poorly received in Germany prior to Nazism, and was officially banned following Hitler’s rise to power, fearing that the film’s message would have a demoralizing effect on Germany’s youth.

all_quiet_ghosts.jpg

Due to its pacifist message, the film has frequently been banned in countries preparing for war. It’s noteworthy that Milestone didn’t make pacifist film during WWII. Some critics have suggested that perhaps it was easier to make a movie like “All Quiet” because its protagonists-losers were Germans and not Americans.

At the time, the film was hailed as courageous, but as some historians pointed out, this was a pacifist film launched profitably during a pacifist period. To be truly “courageous,” the movie should have been made when the country was involved in the midst of a war. The American Legion of Decency was concerned about the sympathetic portrayal of Germans.

Most viewers responded to the film’s noble message the futility of war, any war, as one reviewer noted in 1930: “The League of Nations could make no better investment than to buy the master print, reproduce it in every nation to show every year until the word “war” is taken out of the dictionary.

The movie was extremely popular at the box office, both in the U.S. and in other countries all over the world.

Initially, the film released has a running time of 152 minutes, but later rereleases and the restored version runs about 132 minutes.
All Quiet on the Western Front
Poster depicting a soldier wearing a steel helmet

Theatrical release poster 

Oscar Alert

Nominated for four Academy Awards, “All Quiet on the Western Front,” won two: Best Production (as the Best Picture category was then called) and Director for Lewis Milestone. The other two nominations were for Writing Achievement (George Abbott, Maxwell Anderson, and Del Andrews) and for Arthur Edeson’s Cinematography.

The Writing Oscar went to Frances Marion, for “The Big House,” and the Cinematography Award to Joseph T. Rucker and Willard Van Der Meer for the documentary, “With Byrd at the South Pole.”

If you want to know more about the Oscars, please read my book:

Remake

“All Quiet on the Western Front” was remade in 1979 as a TV movie, but the first version is still the best.

Credits

Directed by Lewis Milestone
Produced by Carl Laemmle Jr.
Written by Maxwell Anderson (adaptation & dialogue); George Abbott (screenplay); Del Andrews (adaptation); C. Gardner Sullivan (supervising story chief), based on All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque
Music by David Broekman
Cinematography Arthur Edeson
Edited by Edgar Adams; Milton Carruth (silent version, uncredited)

Production company: Universal Studios

Distributed by Universal Pictures

Release date: April 21, 1930 (US)