14TH: Oscar Winner Ava DuVernay about the Making of Netflix Most Overtly Political Documentary

The Oscar nominee’s new documentary, 14th, puts Trump administration policies in a disturbing historical context, while serving as an urgent call to action.

 The feature focuses on the 14th Amendment to the Constitution, recent attempts to strip its power, and the ways in which it represents the ideals and viability of American Way.

Ava DuVernay in 2023.
Netflix has set 14th for a brief theatrical run on November 27 ahead of a streaming premiere on December 4.
It’s a companion piece to her Oscar-nominated 2016 documentary 13th, a fiery yet rather simple work that probed mass incarceration and the prison-industrial complex through the amendment that abolished slavery.
The 14th Amendment is not one as clear or simple. As politician Stacey Abrams puts it, the 14th Amendment is the “everything bagel” of constitutional amendments. As historian Eric Foner claims, the 14th is the most important since the Bill of Rights.

The new film comes on the heels of Origin, DuVernay’s 2023 narrative, which resonated with critics, but underperformed with audiences.

She remembers an advice that Spielberg gave her more than a decade ago. Around the release of Selma, her 2014 historical drama that received a best picture Oscar nomination, which launched her into a new, greater visibility. She marveled to Spielberg, “Your name is on so many things–even things that you don’t direct. How do you handle the pressure of delivering every time? What if a project left your fans or peers disappointed? “He said, ‘You make another one, You just keep going.’“ DuVernay has held that advice close ever since.

 

The idea for 14th came to DuVernay in early 2024, when Trump, campaigning to return to the White House, promised to challenge birthright citizenship–one of the rights enshrined in the 14th Amendment.

And once Trump was back in office, the amendment kept turning up in the news: due process, public debt, even its language around “insurrection or rebellion.”

What began as film about one contested constitutional guarantee was becoming larger, and harder to pin down as history was moving on. “This movie kicked my butt because it was like building a plane midflight, much stuff was coming in every day, everything was happening at once,” DuVernay says.

During production, she followed Carla Hayden, the first African American and first woman to serve as librarian of Congress; three weeks later, Hayden was fired. She probed Dr. Lonnie Bunch, the first Black secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, who later retired amid speculation of political pressure.

“My feelings about everything happening in the past three years–politically, culturally–are put into this film,” she says. “At least I’ve felt productive and not going crazy with worry, fear, anger.”

For 14th, DuVernay interviewed experts, scholars and politicians, interweaving their insights with brief snippets of relevant stand-up contents from comedians like Hasan Minhaj, based on her belief that “Comedians are the last frontier of truth-telling.”

The film was made for Netflix, DuVernay’s “home studio,” having worked with the Ted Sarandos run streamer on such projects as the documentary 13th.

But 14th arrives as some of Hollywood’s largest companies have come under scrutiny for their handling of politically sensitive material. Amazon dropped the Sam Altman docudrama Artificial, stating, “We believe that Artificial will be better served if it were released by a different studio,” after striking a major deal with Altman’s OpenAI.

Apple, meanwhile, pushed the Jessica Chastain political-violence thriller, The Savant, by more than a year after the assassination of conservative Charlie Kirk

14th ranks among the more overtly political projects Netflix has evet backed, which made DuVernay wonder whether the company would stay out of her way: “I was hopeful they would continue to support the filmmakers in the way that they’ve established — and they did. I was hoping they would hold their stance under pressure to do otherwise.

The cancellation of Stephen Colbert’s late night show, the turmoil around Jimmy Kimmel firing and rehiring, and Paramount’s settlement of Trump’s lawsuit against 60 Minutes registered strongly with DuVernay. And there was also the short-lived merger agreement between Warner Bros. Discovery and Netflix, which later withdrew its offer.

“Everyone’s afraid, and I’m no exception — I’ve been cautioned about this material and about my points of view on all kinds of things,” DuVernay says. “We’ve seen a total recession in films by certain kinds of people and movies made for certain amounts of money–artists and executives feel a lot less free.”

A former film publicist, DuVernay broke out in the 2010s with the low-budget indies I Will Follow and Middle of Nowhere. Since then, she has made documentaries, limited TV series and big studio movies.  Her 2018 Disney tentpole A Wrinkle in Time disappointed at the box office, but a year later she directed the popular and Emmy-winning When They See Us.

She has grown less interested in being one of Hollywood’s designated spokespeople on representation. “I used to be the poster child of talking about this because I felt like it could make a difference. But what I’ve come to realize is it’s too difficult to do if enough people aren’t on board, and there just aren’t enough people on board. It doesn’t mean give up; it means just do it in other ways.”

The 14th differs from 13th in terms of the audience DuVernay wishes to reach–its attention span and knowledge base. Early on, she ran informal poll of people at the Grove in Los Angeles, asking what they knew about the Civil War, who fought it, what it was about.
DuVernay with Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden. Paul Garnes/Netflix

“The answers were shocking, in terms of people not even having an idea,” she says. “But I don’t want people to feel bad about what they don’t know. I don’t want people to feel overwhelmed.”

The film includes historians, current and former senators, Congress members, and political operatives, but DuVernay also include commentators with big online followings, Ringer podcaster Van Lathan Jr. and Hasan Piker, the left-wing Twitch flamethrower and one of the right’s favorite media bogeymen.

Getting Republicans into the film was a considerable challenge. DuVernay’s team approached nearly 300 GOP officeholders, but only a dozen engaged. That group included conservative Trump critics like strategist Steve Schmidt and former Sen. Jeff Flake.

Florida Rep. Anna Paulina Luna agreed to participate, defending Trump’s policies. “Although I am diametrically opposed to everything she believes, I had appreciation for Paulina flying into New York and sitting with me. No one else would. We asked. I have the receipts.”

She elaborates: “14th is not a Trump takedown. Trump a small cog in a wheel that’s been rolling for a very long time. The current administration is embracing tactics that have been tried-and-true tested and now weaponized in new ways.

She thinks of the movie as an historical record of the period in which it was made: “COVID, wars, Gaza — it’s been quite a decade, and I don’t think we, as people who experience it, appreciate what we’re living through. My question is, how are we getting our arms around that artistically? This film is like an essay. We were writing through it, about what we discovered, how we felt and what it means.”

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter