Nobody’s Fool (1994): Robert Benton’s Serio-Comic Tale of Aging Loser, Starring Paul Newman in Top Form

It’s time to honor the artistry of Paul Newman, a performer who perhaps lacks the splendor of his contemporary, Marlon Brando, but is nonetheless the most accomplished actor of his generation.

Brando’s brilliance impressed audiences with his very first screen performance, The Men (1950), and he continued to dominate the American cinema of the 1950s with his stunning, often eccentric roles in such movies as A Streetcar Named Desire (1951) and On the Waterfront (1954), for which he won a well-deserved Oscar Award. However, a complex, non-conformist personality has arguably been responsible for an erratic career that saw many ups and downs. In the 1970s, you may recall, Brando had some sort of a comeback with The Godfather movies and the controversial The Last Tango in Paris.

In contrast to Brando, Newman has enjoyed a steady, continuous career in an industry known for its fickle taste and lack of stability. The remarkable achievement of Newman is not just his sheer survival–he has made more than 70 movies in four decades–but the incessant development of his craft.

Indeed, Newman has continued to grow and to polish his skills as an actor with almost every assignment. Like Henry Fonda and Burt Lancaster, two distinguished screen actors, who practiced acting up until they were forced to quit due to health–and in Fonda’s case death–Newman’s brand of acting is understated, the kind that gets easily overlooked by critics.

Now, at the age of 70, after finally winning an Oscar Award for Scorsese’s The Color of Money, at his eighth nomination, Newman is the star of Robert Benton’s new drama, Nobody’s Fool, a gentle, low-key tale of an aging loser named Sully, his relationships with family and neighbors, and of a small-town community.

Grade: A- (**** out of *****)

Nobody’s Fool
Theatrical release poster

Playing losers always presents a challenge for actors, because they have to work harder in order to win the audience’s sympathy. I have some reservations about the pacing of this uneven film, though Newman’s performance is flawless.
Newman’s Sully is a 60-year-old construction worker who has made nothing of his life. Divorced from his wife, and alienated from his children, he lives at the house of Miss Beryl (the great Jessica Tandy), his old teacher. As the story begins, Sully is pursuing some legal action with his incompetent lawyer (Gene Saks), another loser who has never won a single case.

Set in a small New York town, the run-down surroundings are most congruent to Sully’s lonely, shabby existence. Adapting to the screen Richard Russo’s novel, Benton structures his character-driven picture with seemingly small and uneventful incidents. By Hollywood’s commercial standards, Nobody’s Fool lacks exciting energy and genuine drama. Yet, on the plus side, the film also defies sentimentality and melodrama, exerting a modest appeal by its faithfulness to the tone of the story and its characters.

Some tension is introduced when Sully’s college professor son, Peter, having lost his teaching job, arrives in town with his wife and two boys. As expected, Sully develops a more meaningful rapport with his grandson than with his son, whom he has not seen in years.

It’s a mature, humanist film, eloquently yet simple, eventful yet plotless tale with strong echoes of a Chekhovian play. The characters are grown-ups and/or elderly, the kinds of which are rarely seen in American movies these days.

In this picture, Benton shows his gifts as a gentle, softspoken director, who guides a large ensemble of stars to put aside their glamor and dig deep into a realistic portraiture of recognizable and utterly relatable individuals.

I have always thought it a major loss that Hollywood has not made better use of Jessica Tandy, mostly known for her stage work–until her 1989 Oscar for Driving Miss Daisy. Tandy, who passed away a few months ago, gives a lovely, elegant performance. Amng ither qualities, she must have had one of the richest voices to have ever graced the American stage.

But the film’s glory belongs to Newman, who here delivers one of his most engaging, seemingly effortless, and richly detailed performances. Newman makes Sully’s loser a human, sympathetic character, despite a life full of disappointments. Still handsome–with beautiful blue eyes and thinning silver hair–Newman has some priceless scenes with Melanie Griffith, who plays an unhappily married woman, envisioning himself as a ladies’ gentleman.

Looking at Newman’s screen credits cumulatively, I can’t help but realize that his specialty and strength have always been in playing misfits, losers and underachievers, who embody the darker side of the American Dream.

Just consider Newman’s roles in Cat on a Hot Tin Roof, The Hustler, Sweet Bird of Youth, Hud, Cool Hand Luke, Absence of Malice, The Verdict, and The Color of Money.

Newman’s 70th birthday is on January 26–I can’t think of a better tribute to his career than honoring his work in Nobody’s Fool.

Alongside with his justifiably celebrated work in The Huster and Hud, Nobody’s Fool exhibits Newman’s limitless range and natural charisma as an actor.

Despite critical acclaim, the film was only moderately popular at the box office.

My Oscar Book

Oscar Context

Oscar Nominations: 2

Actor: Paul Newman

Screenplay (Adapted): Robert Benton

Oscar Awards: None

Oscar Context:

The winner of the Best Actor Oscar was Tom Hanks for Forrest Gump, which also won the Best Screenplay Award for Eric Roth.

Cast
Paul Newman as Donald “Sully” Sullivan
Jessica Tandy as Beryl Peoples
Bruce Willis as Carl Roebuck
Melanie Griffith as Toby Roebuck
Dylan Walsh as Peter Sullivan
Pruitt Taylor Vince as “Rub” Squeers
Gene Saks as “Wirf” Wirfley
Josef Sommer as Clive Peoples Jr.
Philip Seymour Hoffman as Officer Raymer
Angelica Torn as Ruby
Jay Patterson as Jocko
Philip Bosco as Judge Flatt
Catherine Dent as Charlotte Sullivan
Margo Martindale as “Birdy”
Shannah Laumeister Stern as Didi
Alexander Goodwin as Will
Credits: