Anna Lucasta (1958): Drama Starring Ertha Kitt and Sammy Davis Jr. in his Major Role

Directed by Arnold Laven and written by Philip Yordan, Anna Lucasta stars Eartha Kitt, Sammy Davis Jr., and Henry Scott.

It is a remake of the 1949 version (directed by Irving Rapper and starring Paulette Goddard), which itself was an adaptation of the 1936 stage play.

In his first dramatic role, Danny, the character played by Davis was a minor role in the original stage play, but the part was expanded to capitalize on his fame.

At the family home in Los Angeles, patriarch Joe Lucasta learns that his friend Otis has sold a farm, distributing the proceeds to his children. Otis’ son Rudolph is bringing his share to California, where Otis hopes Joe can find a wife for Rudolph. Joe’s son Stanley and son-in-law Frank hope to get the money by being the ones to find Rudolph a wife. Though uninterested in the money, Joe’s wife Theresa suggests youngest daughter Anna, whom Joe put out of the house some time earlier. Theresa believes Anna is good and sees a chance for her to get a fresh start. Stanley, Frank and Frank’s wife Stella regard Anna as a “slut”, but will try to make her seem respectable to deceive Rudolph. Joe objects to their designs on Rudolph’s money and to Anna returning, as he also holds her in low regard. Frank browbeats Joe into going to Anna’s last known whereabouts, a dockside cafe in San Diego, to bring her home.

The cafe is Anna’s regular haunt, where she seduces sailors for meals, drinks and board. As the cafe is closing, she has no place to spend the night. Just then, Danny Johnson arrives looking to renew his acquaintance with Anna. His naval enlistment ending, he asks her to move in with him, though he’s uninterested in marriage. As Anna parties with Danny, Joe arrives and asks her to come home. Anna consents, but after her arrival, Joe angrily rebuffs her efforts to rebuild their relationship.

Rudolph arrives in town. Having expected Rudolph to be a rube, Frank is disappointed to discover that he’s a college graduate, unlikely to be fooled by Anna’s guise of respectability. Furthermore, Rudolph’s only interest is getting a job, the search for a wife having been more his father’s concern than his own. When Rudolph meets Anna, however, he’s smitten and they begin a romance. Anna tells him of her ejection from the household—Joe had become angrily jealous when boys took interest in her, so he falsely accused her of promiscuity and threw her out—and confesses the truth of her life in San Diego. Rudolph says that he still loves her, and Anna agrees to marry him.

Anna is alone in the family home after the wedding, Danny arrives, responding to her letter asking him to come. She informs him that after sending the letter, she fell in love and got married. Danny protests, but Anna is insistent and he surrenders. As Danny is leaving, Joe comes home, declaring his intention to break up Anna’s relationship with Rudolph. Anna begs Joe to allow her to begin a new life and be happy. Danny sticks up for Anna, offering to beat up Joe to prevent him from disrupting her marriage. But Joe says that he’s ruined Rudolph’s job opportunity by informing the employer about Anna’s past. He says that he’ll do the same any place Rudolph seeks work. As Anna breaks down into tears and Joe flies into a rage, Danny pulls Anna away and takes her out of the house.

Danny and Anna head back to San Diego and spend days partying before deciding to move to Brazil. Danny needs time to raise money for ship’s passage, but Anna wants to leave immediately and remembers she has money at the Lucasta home. When she and Danny return to retrieve it while the family is at church, they find Joe on his deathbed. While Danny goes to call a doctor, Anna stays with Joe as he deliriously addresses her as though she were a little girl, calling her his “angel”, as he had before their relationship soured. Joe implores Jesus to watch over Anna, who is so overwhelmed that she’s unable to respond to him before he dies.

Danny observes Anna weep inconsolably over Joe and looks at a joyful picture of the two of them during Anna’s childhood. He then quietly exits the house. As he’s about to drive away, he smiles upon seeing the family, including Rudolph, returning from church. As Danny drives off, Rudolph notices him and realizes that Anna is in the house. He excitedly rushes past the others and runs inside.

Eartha Kitt as Anna Lucasta
Sammy Davis Jr. as Danny Johnson
Frederick O’Neal as Frank
Henry Scott as Rudolph Slocum
Rex Ingram as Joe Lucasta
Alvin Childress as Noah
James Edwards as Eddie
Rosetta LeNoire as Stella
Isabelle Cooley as Katie Lucasta
Georgia Burke as Theresa Lucasta