Irving Rapper’s screen version of Emlyn Williams’ semi-autobiographical play of 1938, “The Corn is Green,” is not one of his best works, nor one of his strongest collaboartions with Bette Davis; that would be the 1942 “Now Voyager.”
In this overly theatrical rendition, shot on Warner’s sound stages, Davis reprises the role that was originated in London by Dame Sybil Thorndike and on Broadway by Ethel Barrymore.
Davis plays Miss Moffat, a turn-of-the-century aging spinster, who arrives as a schoolteacher in a Welsh mining town. She opens her own school in hopes of lowering the town’s illiteracy rate, thus enabling the younger residents to seek out more fulfilling lives than merely working in the mines (where most of their parents are employed).
It’s an uphill battle for Miss Moffat, to say the least. Initially, she runs into resistance from mine-owner Nigel Bruce, who realizes that as soon as the citizens can read and write, they’ll rebel against his rule.
Miss Moffat herself is full of doubts about her idealistic mission—that is, until she meets a young miner (played by John Dall in his film debut), who wants to know “what is behind all those books.” Within two years, Dall makes so much progress that he is qualified for admission in Oxford.
In an unconvincing subplot, Dall gets romantically involved with (Joan Lorring, Oscar nominated), who threatens to derail Moffat’s plan.
A last-minute obstacle involving Dall’s illegitimate child is resolved, when Miss Moffet herself agrees to adopt the baby so that her student can complete his education.
Emlyn Williams himself came from a backward mining town, and was inspired to a better life by a compassionate schoolteacher.
“The Corn is Green” was remade for television by George Cukor in 1978, with Katharine Hepburn as Miss Moffat. But flawed as the Davis version is, it’s still superior to Cukor’s.
Oscar Nominations: 2
Supporting Actor: John Dall
Supporting Actress: Joan Lorring
Oscar Awards: None
“The Lost Weekend” won over Hitchcock’s suspense-thriller “Spellbound” and Leo McCarey’s comedy “The Bells of St. Mary’s,” both starring Ingrid Bergman. The other two nominees were the MGM musical “Anchors Aweigh” and Warner’s noir melodrama “Mildred Pierce,” for which Joan Crawford won the Best Actress for a comeback performance. The most nominated film was “The Bells of St. Mary’s” (8), though it won only one award, for Stephen Dunn’s Sound Recording, perhaps because it was a sequel to “Going My Way,” which swept most of the 1944 Oscars.
In 1945, the winners of the Supporting Acting Oscars were James Dun fro Kazan’s family melodrama, “A Tree Grows in Brooklyn,” and Anne revere as Liz Taylor’s mother in “National Velvet.”
John Dall’s most famous role is arguably that of the arrogant murderer in Hitchcock’s thriller “Rope” (1950); he also had a small part in “Spartacus.”
About Irving Rapper
Irving Rapper joined the Washington Square Players as a stage director while studying at NYU University. He later appeared and directed on Broadway and arrived in Hollywood in the mid-30s as an assistant director and dialogue coach. He worked in such capacities on such Warner films as The Story of Louis Pasteur (1935), The Life of Emile Zola (1937), Four Daughters (1938), Juarez (1939), and Dr. Ehrlich’s Magic Bullet (1940) before making his debut as a full director in 1941.
Though his film work tends to betray his theatrical background and is often stagy and talky, he was occasionally able to overcome this limitation with a flair for developing dramatic plots and directing actors. ”Now Voyager” (1942) is a superior melodrama, a weepie soap opera, beautifully played by Bette Davis and Claude Rains. Most of his output after the late 1940s, when he left Warners, was uninspired.