Vincent Sherman's version of the mythic saga differs from preceding Don Juan versions in literature, poetry, and music. In this adventure, aging swashbuckler Errol Flynn plays the great lover Don Juan De Marana at the service of his Queen Margaret of seventeenth-century Spain (played by Swedish actress Viveca Lindfors).
Sherman and his credited writers, George Oppenheimer and Harry Kurnitz, basing their scenario on Hebert Dalmas's “original” story, didn't want to use the Barrymore storyline, which was more about the great lover and the Borgias in Italy. Final shooting script was also helped by, among others, novelist William Faulkner (uncredited of course).
Much ahead of its time, you could detect some spoofing by Flynn himself of the character and screen image that made him famous in the first place back in the 1930s. In the first satirical and witty chapters, we see Don Juan climbing balconies, wooing women, and encountering irate and jealous husbands.
This turbulent production began shooting in October 1947, but was released, after several interruptions, two years later. Though not as good as Flynn's earlier pictures, “Robin Hood” and “The Sea Hawk,” the film benefits from lush production values, especially Elwood Bredell's sumptuous color cinematography and Max Steiner's magnificent score.
There are also some exciting dueling sequences, and one impressive set piece, a huge staircase in the king's palace, upon which the stirring duel-to-death between Flynn's Don Juan and arch villain Duke de Lorca (Robert Douglas) takes place.
The film's last reel, with scenes set in a torture chamber, in the palace halls, and on the grand staircase, are also striking.
Much publicity at the time was given to the stunt work, with ace Jack Mahoney being the only stuntman willing to take such risks in the difficult stunts.
Oscar nominations: 2
Art Direction-Set Decoration (color): Edward Carrere; Lyle Reifsnider
Costume Design (color): Leah Rhodes, Travilla, and Marjorie Best
Oscar Awards: 1
The winner of the Art Direction Oscar was MGM's remake of “Little Women.”